Dear Mr. President, We Gave You the White House, You Gave Us Tom Vilsack

November 2, 2022

President Joe Biden

The White House

1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20050

Dear Mr. President:

We are writing this letter to you because you have not answered our letter of September 28, 2022. That letter is below.

On behalf of Black farmers and other Socially Disadvantaged Farmers and Ranchers, we encourage you to have Tom Vilsack and staff move swiftly and efficiently to cancel debt for Black farmers. We encourage you to initiate processes that would cancel taxes for recipients of debt cancellation. Additionally, we request a meeting with you to discuss these and systemic changes that need to be made within USDA.

One example that told us how USDA has pointed in the wrong direction was the establishment of an Equity Commission. Their job is to research what has already been addressed. The abhorrent history of USDA is chronicled in a myriad of documents all the way back to the 1920s. To add insult, all recommendations must be cleared and accessible to Tom Vilsack…..the fox watching the hen house.

We, then, see Tom Vilsack’s actions and inactions. We see that Black agrarianism is wilting under the withering heat of racist strategies, consistent with a plantation culture. Time is of the essence. We encourage you to accept his resignation. We desire you to appoint immediately someone more attuned to issues of Black farmers across this country and bring about systemic change at USDA.

The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA of 2022) was a good bill; however, its intent has been bastardized by Tom Vilsack and his leadership. That responsibility rests squarely with Secretary Vilsack. He recently released a document asserting that $800 million from the $3.1 billion had already been released to bring financial security to 13,000 distressed borrowers and that $500 million more will soon be released which will help another 23,000 borrowers.  We are certain that Black farmers are receiving little if any of these funds. We know from credible sources that there are approximately 3,100 Black farmers whose indebtedness is roughly $210 million. We also have been told that heirs property issues now are front and center for him, not debt cancellation.

Our network has informed us that only ONE Black farmer has received total debt cancellation. And now, he has to worry about paying the taxes.

There is no provision within the Bill for the payment of taxes like there was under the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA of 2021) because the Republicans removed it from the Bill. Since the intent of the IRA of 2022 was to relieve the indebtedness of Black farmers, cover their losses, and pay their taxes while also giving them a new lease on life, we ask for you to extend your authority via an Executive Order that cancels taxes. Otherwise, many of the farmers will be behind financially once more rather than being given a new start. We expect not doing so will have a devastating impact on Black farmers’ loss of land and generational wealth.

While debt cancellation is front and center for us at this point in our history, we also are deeply concerned regarding rooting out racism at USDA, creating systemic change within all offices and agencies, and instituting accountability and transparency. These issues have been side-stepped and ignored for decades too long.

In a recent MSNBC interview, Dr. Eddie Glaude tells us who we are as a Nation. It was a brutal yet truthful deconstruction of our country. You can do better. You can also lead USDA out of its “last plantation” mindset into a new Department that serves everyone and not just the white farmers. Discrimination wounds people and destroys families and dreams. The award-winning documentary, “I’m Just a Layman in Pursuit of Justice:” Black Farmers Fight Against USDA, produced by Shoun Hill and Dr. Waymon Hinson, explains it.

Black people of this country delivered the White House to you. Our loyalties are not blind. They are based on the legitimacy of our concerns. Democracy, and with it, equity, for all of God’s children hang in the balance. We are deeply concerned that how the Black farmer issue in Georgia is being mishandled will continue to impact our people. Your silence is interpreted as turning your back on Black farmers as you support Vilsack. There are “political consequences” for both 2022 and 2024 for ignoring or taking for granted the Black vote.

These are our expectations: first, remove Tom Vilsack from his leadership position; second, instruct the USDA team to implement debt cancellation more quickly and efficiently; third, cancel taxes for recipients of debt cancellation; fourth, resolve the backlog of unresolved program and employment complaints; and fifth, meet with a group of Black Farmer Movement representatives to discuss initiating changes within USDA that will bring about systemic change.

On the strength of the Black vote....we gave you the White House. In turn, you give us Tom Vilsack. This is not the justice we voted for.

We are eager to discuss these matters and more with you. We look forward to meeting you very soon. These issues should not be ignored and addressed immediately by your administration.

Respectfully,

Lawrence Lucas
President Emeritus, USDA Coalition of Minority Employees
Representative, Justice for Black Farmers Group
LawrLCL@aol.com
856-910-2399

Is Jesus Coming This Year? Reflections on Birth, Loss, and Expectations Unfulfilled

Is Jesus coming this year? It's that time of the year. The 25th is upon us. At church tonight we'll have a candle light service with the traditional songs and readings. My wife and I have watched a few Christmas television shows, Hallmark and all, as well as the history of the song "Silent Night" for the second, or maybe third year in a row. It never gets old. 

Something, though, is different this year. It's difficult to enter into the season's joy when the vicissitudes of life pinch, pull, and poke. Yes, when a divorce is happening in the family, that impacts us all, children, parents soon to be exes, grandparents on both sides, cousins, and aunts and uncles, and friends on both sides. The Christmas tree is up. Presents were wrapped. The three (one I've yet to see face to face, though her grandmother has) walk in with joy and wonder. They walk about the house, looking and touching, and remembering favorite things from last year or the year before. They were here for a few days and then gone again. Within those few days, there were moments of grace, reading to the two year old, hugging and talking to the four year old, and cooking breakfast and watching Mr. A. Game with the six year old. The breakfast was a long time coming and it had to be deconstructed from an egg-o. Took me a while, but we made it. 

Augustine and the Apostle Paul talk about the divided self, and that's what I have with these children and Christmas. Many of you know exactly what I mean. 

That, however, is only part of my wondering as to whether Jesus is coming this year. There is a second one, a large second one. 

Back earlier this year, and back into 2020, and even 2019, we anticipated a Christmas present, so to speak, for African American farmers. "Christmas present" is used facetiously because it really is about justice, at least a modicum of it, being served. Debt relief was in the Justice for Black Farmers Act of 2020 and then 2021, and then it was skillfully placed within the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021. We had been led to believe that there were 17,000 Black farmers who would receive debt relief. Come to realize, though, there are only 3,200 or so Black farmers who MIGHT receive debt relief. 

The criteria demand that the farmer has previously received a direct loan. That is a steep hill to climb since many Black farmers had been ruled out of receiving loans of any sort, direct or guaranteed. When we look at the latest census data and realize that there are fewer than 45,000 or so Black farmers, and to realize that only 3,200 of them even qualify for debt cancellation, that is a bitter pill to swallow. 

Another bitter pill to swallow, which makes Christmas a little gloomier this year, is the fact that Secretary Vilsack had about 100 days to get the debts cancelled. Then, unbeknownst to only the most blind of us, white farmers of our country filed frivolous and racist lawsuits which stopped debt cancellation in its tracks. I've written about that elsewhere on these pages, so let it be known once more than I consider those lawsuits ridiculous and a part of the puzzle that makes for white America. We knew from the Biden/Harris transition team back in 2020 that what we wanted, debt relief, was called "unconstitutional" by a senior advisor. Lo and behold, that's exactly what the white farmers have claimed it to be. 

Now, in the current day, hidden within the Reconciliation Bill is a modicum of debt cancellation, not just for socially disadvantaged farmers and ranchers, but  for white farmers as well. Again, on another page here in this blog, you'll find my examination of the dollars received by the first six litigants, one of whom is the Agriculture Commissioner for the State of Texas. Those guys received over $523,000 and their counties received over $1.2B. Is that really what you call reverse discrimination when white farmers get all of the advantages? Not as I see it. 

So, the Reconciliation Bill is languishing in the Senate, held up by the Senator from West Virginia. Yes, the one who lives on a yacht in the Potomac and who drives a Maserati, the one who refuses to support a bill that will benefit the people of his state. It has been said that he opposes it because poor families would spend the child support payments on drugs. Shameful. Absolutely shameful. 

So, tomorrow is indeed Christmas Day. All around us people will be celebrating the birth of the Christ child. That is a good thing. Some of us will be in a somewhat different place emotionally. Yes, we can certainly suspend our emotional selves and engage in the joy of the day. Many of us will do just that. At this house, we plan to.

On the other hand, there are people that I care about whose Christmas Day will be clouded with unfulfilled promises. For some of us, it will be about family, and for a bunch of us it will be about the unrelenting burden of indebtedness and injustices perpetrated upon people we care about by the USDA. 

These are the things I'm pondering today. 

I hope your day is good and that it brings to you all of the joy that you can imagine. Along the way, please be mindful of those whose day will be a little more tattered. Please, especially remember that large group of farmers across the land, African American farmers, who deserve better than they are getting. Pray for them and for those persons in Congress who could ease their burdens a little. 

Thank you and God bless you. And may God bless our women and men in the military serving around the world.